Speaker's Purpose

Listening Comprehension
We have discussed purpose a few times so far this semester. Specifically, we introduced the idea when we talked about understanding the organization of ideas. In this lesson, we will practice this listening skill further.

Objectives

  1. Understand the speaker's general purpose
  2. Identify the speaker's purpose in specific statements

General Purpose

As we discuss in the lesson Listening Comprehension: Identify Speaker's Point of View all speakers have a perspective on the topic of the conversation. Related to that perspective, there is often a reason the speaker is participating in the conversation or giving a presentation. There are three main reasons a speaker has for sharing information.

Here is that list of the main reasons that are most common:

A speaker may combine purposes in order to communicate more effectively with the audience. For example, children's shows often combine entertainment with explanations. This keeps the child's attention through humor, interesting characters, and dramatic stories to ultimately teach them a principle or value.

We explore these ideas in more detail in the lesson Listening Strategy: Recognize Organizational Patterns.

Here is an example. Watch this video and identify what the main purpose is. What do you think the secondary purpose is?

Video

Answer Key

Main Purpose: Why are these two men speaking? Well, the main purpose here is to entertain. You should have noticed as you were listening that the speakers were mainly informal, making jokes frequently among the information they gave. This informality is one of the signals. The topic is another signal. This is not a serious topic debated in a serious way. 

Secondary Purpose: By looking at the organization of the information, it is clear that one of the purposes is to present an opinion. The speakers are using persuasive language and the organization of introducing a reason, giving facts and examples, and concluding with a statement of what the listener should do or understand based on what was just said. However, it doesn't seem that either speaker really cares if the audience changes their minds on the topic. The most important thing to the speakers is winning the debate competition. This signals that the persuasive purpose is secondary to the entertainment purpose.

Purpose of Specific Statement

On a smaller scale, it is also important to recognize the purpose behind an individual statement. Pragmatics is the word we use to describe how the context (spoken and cultural) can influence the meaning of what is said. While sometimes the meaning of a statement is clear, others are dependent on an understanding of language patterns and cultural norms. In this section, we will talk about a few of these pragmatic purposes.

Inferential Listening

Inferential Listening means that the listener needs to make some inferences or draw some conclusions based on the information that is heard. Paying close attention to the choice of words, expressions, phrases, and even tone of voice can help determine a speaker's purpose, especially when it is not evident at first glance. One example of this is indirectly expressing skepticism or a skeptical attitude by sometimes exaggerating the information we present and using our tone of voice to express our emotions.  Again, we discuss this in more detail in the lesson Listening Strategy: Inferences.

Bias

Another purpose the speaker might have in stating something is to persuade. To accomplish this, sometimes speakers state their opinions by making a judgment or sharing a preconceived idea about something or someone. In other words, they use bias. Bias means having a tendency to be in favor of or against someone or something and stating that opinion without necessarily showing evidence or support. Thus, the information presented becomes subjective, meaning that it is influenced by our feelings, which renders our message and our purpose less accurate. 

It is important to be able to recognize and be aware of bias as we determine the accuracy of the information presented or received. Here are some forms bias takes in speech:

Generalizations or broad statements. Biased statements sound similar to, 'Everyone likes chocolate.' While many people like chocolate, there are others who may not. A more accurate way of saying this without showing bias could be, "Most/many people like chocolate. Pay attention to words like everyone, all, every, etc. In addition, verbs that make it difficult to verify the information show bias. Example of biased verbs are feel, think, believe, etc. 

Ex: Everyone thinks that chocolate is the best dessert. 

This statement is a generalization because it refers to a very broad category and it uses the verb think which signals the speaker's opinion. However, it is very difficult to verify if the information is accurate. 

Exaggerations are overstatements which make things sound better or worse depending on the audience or purpose. They are used to emphasize and opinion.

Ex. Our neighbors bought enough chocolate for a lifetime.  

For a lifetime is an exaggeration that shows that we think our neighbors bought a lot of chocolate.

If our goal is to persuade others, it is important to share our opinions. It is equally important to appeal to our audience's emotions without using generalizations and exaggerations because they can weaken our argument by making it less accurate and less credible. An example of biased information are the news outlets (see image below on the different news outlets and their tendencies). In the world of news, there are many perspectives on the same subject depending on political views and affiliations. It is important to be aware of such a bias so that we can get the full picture and form our own informed opinions. You can read two pieces of news on the exact same event, but get a different version of it depending on the news outlet's opinions and perspectives. 

Exercise 1

Take a look at the following examples of news covering the same event: Donald Trump's speech on January 6th when people attacked the Capitol in Washington DC. As you answer the following questions keep in mind that NBC News is a Lean Left (image above) news outlet (more democratic) and FOX News is a Right news outlet (more republican). Pay attention to the bias expressed in both of these examples based on their political views. 

1. How is the content different?

2. What impressions or opinions do you get from each video?

3. What is the purpose in these examples?

Videos

Answer Key

  1. In the NBC News report, Donald Trump is shown in a less favorable light as only the part of his speech that can be construed as inciting to violence is shown. The news outlet cut out the rest of his speech. In the second report, FOX News is depicting Donald Trump as calling for peace and inviting the protesters to go home and to be peaceful. This excerpt is taken from the same speech as the one above it, but similarly it only shows the parts that depict Donald trump as calling for peace.
  2.  In both videos the purpose is to persuade. They are both presenting only the parts of the speech that support their own opinion which contradicts the other.

Exercise 2

Individual Activity: Present a Purpose

  1. During the week, find a clip that illustrates a speaker's purpose (preferably showing bias or a skeptical attitude). 
  2. You will show the clip to your class and have them identify the purpose.

Group Activity: Judge

Your teacher will assign you to a group. Follow the steps below.

  1. Choose one person from your group to be the judge. The judge will SECRETLY decide on a topic for the conversation. This person will wait to tell the group the topic until step 3.
  2. The teacher will tell the class what the purpose of the conversation will be.
  3. When you enter your breakout rooms, the judge will tell the group the topic.
  4. The group will begin their conversation.
  5. Each member of the group will choose a secondary purpose and include some ideas in the conversation to show that secondary purpose.
  6. The judge will listen closely to the conversation.
  7. When the timer stops, the judge will guess what each member of the group's secondary purpose was.
  8. Choose a new judge for the group and repeat.

Class Activity: Pause & Poll

  1. Your teacher will show you a video (or parts of a long video).
  2. Listen carefully for clues of the speaker's main purpose and for the purpose of individual statements.
  3. The teacher will pause the video and ask you a question using the Zoom poll to check that everyone recognized the speaker's purpose.


This content is provided to you freely by EdTech Books.

Access it online or download it at https://edtechbooks.org/advanced_mid_listening__speaking/identify_speakers_purpose.